91高清黑料

Brown Rice vs White Rice: Which One Is Better for You?

Turkey breast (white meat, no skin)Chicken breast 听(white meat, no skin)
Iron0.7 mg (4% DV)0.45mg (2% DV)
Sodium99 mg (4% DV)360mg (26% DV)
Zinc1.7 mg (16% DV)0.9 mg (8% DV)
Magnesium32 mg (8% DV)28 mg (7% DV)
Phosphorus230 mg (18% DV)229 mg (18% DV)
Potassium249 mg (10% DV)359 mg (14% DV)
Copper0.063 mg (7% DV)0.047 mg (5% DV)
Selenium30.2 mcg (55% DV)30.6 mcg (55% DV)
Turkey breast 听(white meat, no skin)Chicken breast (white meat, no skin)Turkey (dark, meat, no skin)Chicken (dark meat, no skin)
Calories147 calories161 calories173 calories178 calories
Protein30 g30 g27.7 g23.2 g
Total Fat2.1 g3.5 g6 g8.7 g
Saturated Fat0.6 g0.75 g1.8 g2.4 g
Sodium99 mg (4% DV)360mg (26% DV)104 mg (4% DV)95 mg (4% DV)
Niacin11.8 mg (74% DV)10.3 mg (63% DV)7 mg (44% DV)6 mg (38% DV)
Vitamin B60.8 mg (62% DV)0.87 mg (67% DV)0.44mg (34% DV)0.3 mg (23 % DV)
Zinc1.7 mg (16% DV)0.9 mg (8% DV)3.5 mg (32 % DV)2.1mg (19% DV)
Cholesterol80 mg (27%)98 mg (33% DV)128 mg (42% DV)75 mg (25% DV)

People have consumed rice for centuries. Most historians credit China for domesticating the crop in the Yangtze River basin over 10,000 years ago. Its popularity continues in modern times, with this carbohydrate at the base of cuisines, from Thai dishes to southern red beans and rice.1

Recently, white rice has gotten a bit of a bad reputation among the diet-conscious crowd. It鈥檚 important to note that it still has nutritional value, even though it might not be ideal for all situations. White rice is natural; it simply has part of it removed. While it may not be the healthiest type of rice, it has uses.

For example, those living with type 2 diabetes striving to stay below 100 grams of carbs daily might avoid white rice for the impact on their glycemic index. However, it鈥檚 invaluable for anyone needing a quick dose of energy, from distance runners to those recovering from illness.

Salad bowl on a white polygonal plate.

Discover how your body responds to what you eat, and make small changes to hit your health goals

What's the Difference Between White Rice and Brown Rice?

The primary difference between brown and white rice is:

  • Brown rice is a whole grain, meaning it consists of three layers. The fibrous outer layer is the germ, the nutrient-rich middle is the bran, and there鈥檚 a white, starchy center or endosperm. That ranks it with other whole grains, like whole wheat and quinoa.
  • White rice is a refined grain where manufacturers remove the germ and bran, which extends its shelf life. Some believe it also improves texture.

In nature, rice comes in various colors, from the light tans of basmati and arborio strains to the inky colors found in low-glycemic black rice and some species of jasmine. While some wild varieties are pale enough to be nearly white, you won鈥檛 find the shocking brightness seen in refined products before processing.

The endosperm or middle portion still has nutritional value, containing carbohydrates, protein, and some trace B vitamins and minerals. However, the germ contains a far bigger dose of vitamins, minerals and healthy fats that your body needs. That鈥檚 why people claim brown rice is healthier, but it doesn鈥檛 mean that white rice is unhealthy.2

Is Brown Rice Better Than White Rice?

It鈥檚 fair to say brown rice is more nutritious than white rice because it maintains more of the plant鈥檚 original goodness. It鈥檚 also gentler on your glycemic index, which measures how carbs impact your blood sugar levels. Your body breaks down foods with a high GI more quickly, which can lead to spikes and crashes. Over time, overeating such foods increases your risk of type 2 diabetes and other associated conditions like heart disease.

White rice has a glycemic index of 87, making it a high-GI food. Brown rice, conversely, is considerably lower at 68. The difference lies in the extra fiber the germ and bran provide, making it absorb more slowly.

Therefore, you might stick with brown rice if you follow a low-glycemic diet. However, white rice might be your better bet when your body鈥檚 reserves deplete. You might also investigate other low-carbohydrate rice alternatives such as riced cauliflower and broccoli to further lower the effects of your meal on your blood sugar.3

Benefits of Brown Rice

Brown rice is healthy with a host of benefits. Here鈥檚 what you can gain from eating more of this grain.

1. Helps Reducing Cholesterol

Brown rice contains a special antioxidant known as cycloartenyl ferulate (CAF). It鈥檚 a unique hybrid compound of polyphenol and phytosterol that can lower fat in the blood.4

You have two types of cholesterol: LDL and HDL. LDL is the 鈥渂ad鈥 kind of cholesterol that can result in fat buildup in your arteries, but adding more brown rice to your diet may prevent it.

2. Lowers Risk of Diabetes

Brown rice is considered a slow-digesting carb, which can lower your risk of developing type 2 diabetes. Whenever you eat a carbohydrate, your body secretes insulin in response to transport glucose molecules to their destinations. Slow-digesting carbs let this sugar enter your bloodstream more slowly, giving your body time to adjust and secrete the appropriate insulin amount.

Benefits of White Rice

It might surprise you to learn white rice also has unique benefits, including the following.

1. Contains Anti-Nutrients

Brown rice contains antinutrients called lectins, substances that inhibit the absorption of other nutrients and can increase irritation in people with leaky gut. White rice has fewer anti-nutrients, making it a better choice for people with sensitivities to lectins.5

2. Supports Digestion

Sometimes, you want a fast-digesting carb, such as when recovering from illness or intense exercise. While quick digestion will spike your glycemic index, it also provides a necessary energy boost and enables your body to store glycogen for future use when it may lack the energy to digest more complex meals.

Takeaway: Brown Rice Vs. White Rice

Here are 91高清黑料鈥 quick tips to help you decide between brown and white rice at your next meal.

Nutrition

It鈥檚 time to square off white rice versus brown rice nutrition. Brown rice contains the following per 1-cup serving:6

Brown Rice White Rice
Calories 248kcal 205kcal
Protein 5.54g 4.25g
Fiber 3.23g 0.63g
Carbohydrates 51g 44.6g

Glycemic Index

High glycemic index foods would be less optimal for people living with diabetes because these foods are more likely to cause blood sugar spikes and dips. Therefore, those living with diabetes might want to stick with brown rice or consult their doctor before using white rice.7

It is valuable to note that cooking methods can influence the glycemic index of any type of rice, with overcooking or cooking with fat potentially increasing the index. Cooled, cooked rice has a听 lower glycemic index due to the formation of resistant starch. Understanding the impact of these factors is crucial for individuals, particularly those with diabetes, aiming to manage their blood sugar levels effectively.

Each individual has different reactions to foods, so we also recommend experimenting to see if brown rice or white rice cause significant spikes for you.

Vitamins

Brown rice contains the following vitamins:9, 10

Brown Rice (%DV) White Rice (%DV)
Thiamine (B1) 0.2mg 0.07mg
Riboflavin (B2) 0.07mg 0.016mg
Niacin (B3) 2.6mg 1.62mg
Pantothenic acid (B5) 0.38mg 0mg
Vitamin B6 0.12mg 0.093mg
Folate 9碌驳 8碌驳
Choline 9.2mg 1.3mg
Vitamin E 0.17mg 0mg

Minerals

Brown rice also contains the following minerals:9, 10

Brown Rice White Rice
Calcium 3mg 3mg
Iron 0.56mg 0.20mg
Magnesium 39mg 12mg
Phosphorus 103mg 43mg
Potassium 86mg 35mg
Sodium 4mg 1mg
Zinc 0.71mg 0.42mg
Copper 0.11mg 0.069mg
Manganese 0.97mg 0.503mg
Selenium 5.8碌驳 7.5碌驳

White rice contains most of the same nutrients but in smaller amounts. The endosperm has trace amounts, but most of the good stuff resides in the bran.

Salad bowl on a white polygonal plate.

Discover how your body responds to what you eat, and make small changes to hit your health goals

References

  1. History of Rice Cultivation. (n.d.). .
  2. Reach for the Right Rice 鈥 Nutrition and Food Safety. .
  3. Samuel, Joshua. (2022, January 21) 鈥淭he 10 Best White Rice Alternatives.鈥
  4. 鈥淩esearchers Uncover the Secret to the Health Benefits of Brown Rice.鈥 .
  5. C. I. (2023, February 21). The 4 top antinutrients to avoid. Longevity.Technology Lifestyle | Health, Fitness & Technology. https://longevity.technology/lifestyle/the-4-top-antinutrients-to-avoid/.
  6. FoodData Central. .
  7. 鈥淭ypes of Rice.鈥 The Rice Association, .
  8. 鈥淲ondering What All the Fuss Is about Forbidden Rice?鈥 Cleveland Clinic, .

Frequently Asked Questions

Is White Rice Whole Grain?

White rice is not a whole grain. Whole grains maintain the fibrous germ and bran, which makes them absorb more slowly. Whole grains have a lower glycemic index on average than refined grains, including white rice.

What Is the Healthiest Type of Rice?

Fortunately, all types of rice are healthy for you, although you should consume white rice in moderation to avoid blood sugar spikes. Eating it with other fiber-rich foods like broccoli can slow absorption. There are more than 40,000 cultivated rice varieties, so it鈥檚 tough to pick a definitive winner6. However, forbidden black rice is an heirloom species that鈥檚 even more potent than blueberries in antioxidant content, so give it a try the next time you feel creative in the kitchen.8

Does Brown and White Rice Affect Blood Sugar Differently?

Yes. In brown rice versus white rice for glycemic index impact, brown rice wins the slow race. It won鈥檛 spike your blood sugar as much and is better for people with diabetes who need to monitor their carbohydrate intake.

What Are the Negatives of Rice?

You鈥檒l notice brown rice and white rice have nearly the same number of calories. However, brown rice might be better than white rice for weight loss because of the glycemic index effect. When blood sugar spikes wear off, they leave you hungry, spurring cravings that can compel you to overeat.

No items found.